Critic's Review
Stephen Thomas Erlewine, All Music Guide
The Replacements half-heartedly tried to expand their reach on Hootenanny, and they followed through on that album's promise on Let It Be. Kicking off with the country-rock shuffle of "I Will Dare," the record explodes into a series of pseudo-hardcore ravers before hitting Paul Westerberg's piano-driven rumination, "Androgynous," one of four major ballads that cuts to the core of Midwestern suburban alienation. "Sixteen Blue" is one of the definitive teenage anthems of the '80s, while "Unsatisfied" rages in despair and Westerberg rarely was more affecting than the solo performance of "Answering Machine." All four, along with "I Will Dare," form the core of Westerberg and the Replacements' canon, and are enough to make Let It Be a cornerstone post-punk album, even if the rest of the record pales next to the songs. All the remaining songs are convincing garage rockers, even if they reveal the Replacements' former punk stance to be a bit of a pose -- a cover of Kiss' "Black Diamond" comes off as a tribute, as does the co-opting of Ted Nugent's "Cat Scratch Fever" for "Gary's Got a Boner." Furthermore, the original numbers lean toward the Faces, leaving the Ramones behind, and while everything except "Seen Your Video," which now sounds as dated as a "disco sucks" rant, consists of bracing rockers, they're a bit inconsequential and point the way toward the band's deadly fascination with classic rock.
