Write a Review

Your Take
Tell the world what you think about
1930-44: The Alternate Takes by
Cab Calloway!
Critic's Review
arwulf arwulf, All Music Guide
For the life of him, Cab Calloway could never understand why anybody would want to buy an instrumental record by the Cab Calloway Orchestra. After all, he was the star. He was the one who everybody paid good money to hear. Who cared about Chu Berry, Walter "Foots" Thomas, Ben Webster, Ike Quebec, Doc Cheatham, Dizzy Gillespie, or Jonah Jones? Cab was the star. For this reason, any Calloway recording without a vocal automatically holds a special place in the hearts of classic jazz lovers worldwide. Eight of the 25 tracks on this album are instrumentals. While that might not seem like an awful lot, it is a noticeably higher percentage than what is found on many other Calloway retrospectives. Whether they were alternate takes or sides that were originally left unissued (probably because there was no vocal!), this disc contains a small gold mine because of wordless performances like "Pluckin' the Bass" -- that great feature for young Milt Hinton -- and Hilton Jefferson's alto saxophone outing "Lonesome Nights." Benny Carter did a bit of arranging for this band, and left his persona etched into the titles "Calling All Bars" and "The Lone Arranger." A hot new mode of jamming becomes apparent in 1941 with "Special Delivery" and has completely transformed the entire band by 1944's "Cruisin' With Cab," heard here on a rare V-Disc pressing. All of this is not meant to deflate Calloway's importance and splendor as a flashy vocalist. This album follows the evolution of his voice and the bands that backed it up, from their modest beginnings in 1930 through 14 years of stylistic transformation. Aside from those obligatory hits "Minnie the Moocher" and "The Scat Song," the listener must endure a disturbingly offhand series of references to delirium tremens and dipsomania in "Jitter Bug," a song urging everyone to mix all their liquors together into one noxious, pernicious potion. Probably seemed like a good idea at the time. The trajectory of gradual musical modernization culminates with Cab's mature hip vocalizing style, best typified by "A Chicken Ain't Nothin' But a Bird." The strangest surprise of the entire package involves the inclusion of three V-Discs recorded in 1943. Lena Horne is heard in front of a twisted mutant version of the Calloway orchestra augmented by a Hollywood string section. She sings two sugar pop tunes and one fizzy arrangement of "Diga Diga Doo." Blindfolded, most listeners would not ever have been able to guess that the band behind Horne had anything whatsoever to do with Cab Calloway or the many outstanding musicians who worked with him over the years.