GAMES: GameSpot: Best of 2008 | GameFAQs | SportsGamer MUSIC: Last.fm | MP3.com MOVIES: Metacritic | Movietome TV: TV.com
advertisement
iPod in the crosshairs
By Jim Welte - MP3.com
January 6, 2006 at 01:34:00 PM | more stories by this author

Next generation of competitors are lining up to take on Apple's vaunted portable music player juggernaut.

Who's ready to take on the big dog?

Digital music services like Napster and Rhapsody have long decried the sad state of portable digital music players on the market, saying that the lack of compelling devices has aided Apple in its quest for dominance of the digital music space.

But in the wake of this week's Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas, a whole slew of competitors are lining up in the hopes of dethroning the iPod juggernaut, although most would likely settle for putting even a dent into the iPod family's 70-percent market share.

SanDisk, Samsung, and Toshiba all unveiled their hopeful iPod slayers this week, while other previously announced rivals from Creative, iRiver, and Sony hope to do the same.

Both SanDisk and Samsung unveiled devices Thursday that hope to take on the pencil-thin iPod nano. Both use flash memory to obtain a sleeker look than previous models.

SanDisk's Sansa e200 series is a 6GB flash-based player with a 1.8-inch color LCD screen and nearly identical dimensions to the nano. It retails for $299. SanDisk also offers 2GB and 4GB versions of the e200, priced at $199 and $249, respectively. The Sansa e200 series is set to arrive in stores in March.

Samsung's new YP-Z5 is also about the same size as the nano, although slightly thicker. It comes with either 2GB and 4GB capacities and a 1.8-inch color LCD. Like the iPod, it doesn't have an FM tuner, although the SanDisk Sansa e200 does. The YP-Z5 will arrive in stores in February.

Toshiba is releasing its new Gigabeat S30 and S60 in March, with storage capacities of 30GB and 60GB. Based on Microsoft's Portable Media Center, the new players have 2.4-inch high-resolution screens, nearly matching the 2.5-inch screen of the video-ready iPods announced last October. The S30 and S60 players retail for $299 and $399, respectively.

These entries join the recent debut from the Creative Zen Vision: M, announced in December with striking similarities to the iPod amid searing words from Creative boss Sim Wong Hoo.

The Vision: M has a 30GB hard drive, 2.5-inch color screen, and touch control system below the screen, all identical features with the latest iPod, except that the Vision: M opts for an oval scroll bar instead of the iPod's round one.

In making the announcement, Sim told BBC News that Creative plans to "pursue aggressively" a US patent the company garnered last August on a system used to navigate music on digital players. The US patent is for the interface within which songs are organized and navigated on a music player using a hierarchical system of three or more screens.

When Creative won the interface patent in August, it said it would apply to several competing products that use similar navigation systems, including Apple's line of iPods.

Although it didn't unveil any new portable audio devices at CES, iRiver was showing off its U10 series, which feature a large screen but smaller storage capacities than the iPod at 512MB and 1GB. The devices retail for $199 and $249, respectively.

Sony showed off its NW-A1000 and NW A3000 at CES, prompting Piper Jaffray senior research analyst Gene Munster to issue a research note saying, "We continue to be shocked at how Sony's devices miss the mark despite the resources that are being put into creating a competitive product. The devices feature a non-color OELD display that cannot display photos or video and the navigation of the device is not user-friendly."

Munster wrote that he expects the iPod to continue to dominate in 2006, despite the growing abundance of rival portable audio devices on the market.

"While we found that there are several more legitimate devices out now versus what we saw at last year's CES, we still believe Apple has the market beat in form factor, intuitive user interface, and the 'cool factor,'" he wrote.

As Microsoft chairman Bill Gates called up pop star Justin Timberlake onto the main stage at CES to help him hype the Urge digital music service the software giant is rolling out with MTV, Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer was admitting to CNET's News.com that the company needs to do better on the portable-device front.

"We've got a lot of work to do," he said. "On the PC, our stuff is still the most popular stuff out there. It's not true in the portable-device space, and I think we have to do some stuff to simplify the experience."

The hoped-for ace in the hole for rivals of both iPod players and the iTunes music store, it seems, is the all-you-can-eat subscription model industry insiders have been touting for years as the future of the digital music space.

Napster, Rhapsody, Yahoo!, and AOL's MusicNow offer such services, as does indie-friendly eMusic, but none have been able to cut into the dominance of iTunes, which lets users download individual songs for 99 cents and does not support subscriptions.

"We've been pretty encouraged by the devices we've seen," Napster Chief Technology Officer Bill Pence told News.com. "We think they're headed in the right direction."

Back to Today's News »

13 Comments

Oldest First | Newest First
cute menu
Posted 05/25/2009 1:20pm
J'ai trouve un bon nombre de choses intresting ici.
Posted 05/25/2009 12:00pm
Ou est l'arret d'autobus le plus proche?
Posted 05/25/2009 9:26am
yo sword slinger...

the samsung FLASH player has videos.



Same gigs (or more) as Nano.

Same price as Nano.

But has videos?



get outta here with that BS, i'd get a Sansa.
Posted 01/12/2006 4:45pm
I used to want ipod, knew bout psp but was like nah. Until my brother bought psp, I feel in love with it. Even though its hard 2 handle in palm of ur hands, but who cares, i loved it. Great feathers, you could do enything besides music.

Posted 01/09/2006 6:46pm
I think Ipod is weak compared to other players. The Nano and Mini. while being sleek and all, have no voice recorder, no fm tuner, no line encoding, and they pretty much just play music. For nearly the same price, Samsung and Creative players offer much more functionality. Sony has it's PSP, and now there's the gigapack which comes with the 1 GB memory stick. After 3 mp3 players failing on me in a row, I bought the PSP, and now use it as my mp3 player. But it's also a video player, and on its 4.7 inch display, it easily blows ipod video out of the water. It also views photos, browses the internet, has customizable backgrounds, plays UMD movies, and has a spectacular line-up of games, if your looking for that kind of thing. If it's all about music for you, then I'd check out Creative or Samsung's players instead.
Posted 01/08/2006 5:01pm
the creative zen sleek photo is better: got 20gb of storage, colour screen, 15hr battery life and cool scroll wheel
Posted 01/08/2006 6:02am
I got a Dell DJ. 30 gigs, battery has a life of 5 hours, charges fully in 15 minutes. The dial design for scrolling is much more convienient than the circular pad of the iPod. If you're looking for something worthwhile, check out the Dell DJ...for $50 cheaper than an iPod
Posted 01/07/2006 9:31am
They just can't beat the scroll wheel and the coolness of the iPod. Besides, none of them are trying anything different, most of them have the exact same amount of gigs for the exact same price. They're not going to get anywhere by just adding videos, photos, and making glossy players; these companies need to go the extra mile.
Posted 01/07/2006 8:55am
i wish that mp3 was like 100 dollers so i can buy it
Posted 01/06/2006 7:00pm
iPods are still better.
Posted 01/06/2006 4:54pm
And bigger.
Posted 01/06/2006 3:54pm
i wish mp3 players were cheaper
Posted 01/06/2006 3:53pm
Sign up now to post a comment!
advertisement

Latest News

Video download comes to iPhone and Touch
Video download comes to iPhone and Touch
Apple announces that the mobile iTunes store used on the iPhone and iPod Touch will soon be able to download purchased and rented video content.

Related Hardware

Apple iPod (30GB) Apple iPod (30GB)
A thin and light body, a big video-friendly screen, and a totally fair price make the newest Apple iPod the best one to date.
Apple iPod (60GB) Apple iPod (60GB)
A thin and light body, a big video-friendly screen, and a totally fair price make the newest Apple iPod the best one to date.
Apple iPod Nano (4GB) Apple iPod Nano (4GB)
The pricey Apple iPod Nano is thin, beautiful, and feature filled, but 2GB or 4GB may not be enough for many power users.
Toshiba Gigabeat (20GB) Toshiba Gigabeat (20GB)
Toshiba's sleek-looking Gigabeat series offers eye-catching innovations but is marred by a sloppy interface and operational quirks.
iRiver U10 (1GB) iRiver U10 (1GB)
The pricey iRiver U10 is a superbly designed MP3 player that is both easy to use and packed with pretty much every feature in the book. But Apple won't be quaking in its boots until iRiver ups its capacity to 2GB and 4GB.
Apple iTunes Apple iTunes
Apple iTunes remains the easiest way to rip, organize, play, and buy digital music--and now video, as well.
Yahoo Music Unlimited Yahoo Music Unlimited
If you can overlook its bugs, Yahoo Music Unlimited's ultralow subscription fee makes it a compelling alternative to Napster To Go and Rhapsody To Go.

Tags

add
Be the first to tag !
Data Warehouse Clear Gif