GAMES: GameSpot: Best of 2008 | GameFAQs | SportsGamer MUSIC: Last.fm | MP3.com MOVIES: Metacritic | Movietome TV: TV.com

Where is Edward Murrow when we need him?

Lin has probably said pretty much everything that can be said in her 'blog about the appalling behaviour of TV.com in its decision to create duplicate guides for shows beginning their airing run in the US. It all began with The Sarah Jane Adventures, a show I have contributed to in the past and one that being part of the Whoniverse has a place dear to my heart, but the rot has spread, and it seems it is happening not just to UK based shows, but to Canadian as well. I can easily see it jumping to Australian, New Zealand in fact pretty much any English-speaking country is ripe for this particular form of racism, and whilst I dislike the word and all it implies I cannot help but think it is apt here.

This is not a business decision on CNET's part, or if it is it is a bad one. The reason this site is successful is the users, global participants who have a shared passion for the products of the tv industry and come to this place to discuss and debate, to argue and agree, to console and comfort over what happens to our 'on-screen' friends. Without those users, the sponsors and advertisers would not get the amount of exposure that they do, they would not be linked to a successful and vibrant community and without seeing a bang for their buck they would leave. How can annoying your major asset be a good way to keep a business going?

We have to fight this, it's no longer on the beaches, landing grounds, or in the fields and in the streets, but once again we will defend to the death our native product, and aiding each other like good comrades to the utmost of our strength.

Spread the word to all you know, and let the halls of CNET ring with the voice of our displeasure.

*Edit* Well it looks like the first battle has been won and the duplicate guides are being removed, in fact that was the message I got back on the couple of subs I put in requesting my original subs removal from the duplicate guide. There was even a message to submit them to the original guide as that was the right place. It made me laugh. Oh and I noticed the comments on the front page from the Torchwood finale 'Thanks to the Brits our guide has trivia, quotes and more!' Hysterical.

Still the war is not yet won, and we need to keep up the pressure and let tv.com know just how we can work together.

Posted by nhubi, 04/17/2008 11:13pm
13 Comments  | Post Comment Sign up to post comments!

Comments

Previous   |   Next
Page: 1
I definately think a massive boycott of submissions to the new guides is what we should do because without our input the new duplicate guides will look very bare and hopefully TV.com will come to there senses and remove them
Posted 04/18/2008 2:40am
...
Posted 04/18/2008 2:56am
As Lin says the response has been absolutely massive coming from all corners of the UK and spreading outwards to people who edit UK guides, and thankfully now to users it doesn't even concern!
Luckily it has yet to affect any of my guides but if it does they'll certainly know about it!
Posted 04/18/2008 4:21am
I definitely think their business sense led them on the wrong path here. Reminds me of the uproar over at Gamespot a few months back...
Posted 04/18/2008 4:35am
I'm with you all the way on this one, nhubi. I know you're a dedicated submitter to both Who and Torchwood (as am I) and if they duplicate the guides for these two shows, I am leaving the site. I WILL NOT tolerate my hard work being ripped off and someone else profiting from simply copying and pasting stuff that we've worked so hard on.
Posted 04/18/2008 5:06am
You know it does have the same definition as segregation... doesn't it? It's not just me, right? . I do hope they take our concerns to heart and do something about it because it is just appaling (sp?).
Posted 04/18/2008 5:25am
geez, i had no idea this was going on... that is completely unfair... and very stupid... why do they need duplicate shows (i mean isn't it already bad enough that they have to make duplicate shows starring americans) i mean we don't complain about the airdates being wrong for our own countries... if their going to make duplicates soon everyone will want one specific to their own country... if not it is a bit unfair that only america has it... though i wouldn't want separate pages... one show, one page... that's how it works.

grrr humbugs about Life on Mars, Spaced and Kath and Kim (though I hate Kath and Kim)
Posted 04/18/2008 5:33am
I've just posted on Islander's blog on the same topic, and I'll be moving to Lin's next. I just have to say that we are going to win this, and I think it's an incredibly foolish move by TV.com.
Posted 04/18/2008 7:21am
It flat out sucks. I didn't love the reply in the UK thread that said TV.com has the right to use your submissions as they see fit. Just because they have the right doesn't mean it is right.

I HATE when people skirt an argument like that.
Posted 04/18/2008 4:15pm
Yeah, another reason to hate the mods. Come on, some of us worked hard on the UK guides. And now, it's gonna be all for nothing.
Posted 04/18/2008 5:18pm
I will only be keeping the US air dates on the SJA guide until Monday... after that, it's going back to UK - I'm with you Nhubi, I'm making a stand, and if they don't like it - they can stuff it!
Posted 04/19/2008 11:54pm
well if this guy wants to segrogate the americans from the rest of us more the fool him i'm sure our US friends would rather come talk/debate with the rest of us than go on some desolate TV thread. Lets all stick together over this!!
Posted 04/24/2008 5:04pm
Nhubi -

First Edward R. Murrow sighting in a while (grew up watching his show every week and he might be why I smoke more than any other reason). I am hoping that all of the English-speaking non U.S. dotcommers get exactly what they're asking for.

It takes a solid front and majority agreement on what is needed so that they will not just put this down as 'some dissatisfied customers'.

(p.s. our paths cross often yet we are not co-tracking so I will fix that as soon as I'm done here).

Raven-haired, hazel-eyed... is that Witchy Woman playing in the background?

Jon
Posted 05/07/2008 6:42pm
Previous   |   Next
Page: 1

Post a Comment

Profile

nhubi
last online: 5:21am Mar 18, 2009
member since: Oct 18, 2006
Rank:
Level:
My Other Profiles:
GameSpot TV.com MovieTome

Friends' Recent Blogs

Data Warehouse Clear Gif